Consumer
February 25, 2025

Deconstructing P&L: What Most Founders Misunderstand

How It All Started

Somewhere during 2024, I was at yet another event, watching panelists swap anecdotes and generic advice, when it hit me "Can events truly deliver value to founders beyond networking opportunities?”

So come November, we created something different - The Consumer Unicorn Blueprint. The intention was to merge wisdom (and warmth) from successful founders with the cold reality of data and benchmarks. We chose the (obvious, but criminally under-used) P&L statement to structure the discussion.

Kickoff: The Event

We were fortunate to have exceptional panellists who were willing to participate in this experiment:
> Varun Alagh (Honasa/Mamaearth)  
> Abhiraj Bhal (Urban Company)  
> Revant Bhate (Mosaic Wellness)  
> Avnish Bajaj (Z47)

The event received rave reviews (in our biased view, at least). In any case, energized by the format we decided to launch this series. If the event was the first step, step two begins with what was learnt and build on it.  

Reimagining the P&L: More Strategy, Less Accounting Trauma

When most founders hear ‘P&L’ they’ll instinctively fire up a spreadsheet, thinking unit economics, cost levers, runway and burn rates. Here, we implore you to look at the P&L in more imaginative ways.

Take Gross Margin – the mind races to COGS, pricing, discounting etc. But reframe it as "What to build vs. what to buy" and suddenly you're having a different conversation. It's the difference between:

Company A: "We invest in designers, who can create great prints and silhouettes.  We do this 3 quarters ahead of the season, sourcing product from vendors.

Company B: "We built a supply chain that goes from social trend to store shelves in 3 weeks flat."

Same category, wildly different businesses. Look no further than Zara (Inditex) to see the magic an innocent question (build vs buy) can unlock. Shein, Lenskart and Country Delight, I’d argue, drank the magic potion too. With this in mind – we chose to reframe the P&L into questions that can help a Founder choose/craft her business model.

Deconstructing the P&L

The Strategic Questions  

Each of these “reframes” have a ‘timing and relevance’ component to it. For the 2024 edition, we decided to pick the following sub-themes to unpack these strategic choices.

1. Revenue ( TAM -> Where to Play)

A consultant’s way of asking: "Should you create a new market or fight for scraps in an existing one?" Consider the India Opportunity (below). We're tracking similar GDP per capita numbers to China in 2007. What happened next in China? Explosive growth. The question isn't just about capturing market share - it's about riding the right wave at the right time.

The India Opportunity

2. Gross Margins (COGS -> What to Build vs. Buy)

Or: which parts of the value chain should you own, and which should you outsource? Key considerations:
• When backward integration creates competitive advantage
• Identifying and capturing value chain profit pools
• Strategic choices in servitization and private labels

3. Contribution Margin (CM 1/2/3 -> How to Build)

The blueprint for sustainable growth loops.  We examined:
• Optimizing channel and category mix
• Forward integration strategies
• Building sustainable performance, brand, and user growth loops

4. Bottomline ( EBITDA, Cashflows, RoCE -> How to Sustain)

Because, eventually, everyone runs out of other people's money.

Centered on:
• Prioritizing cash flow over EBITDA when appropriate
• Deconstructing ROCE to improve returns
• Working capital optimization techniques

Coming up
This is just the appetizer. Over the next few weeks, we'll dive deeper into each section of our framework, starting with "Where to Play" - categories, TG, premiumization, monetization and how our Panelists reframe the “Market creation” conundrum.  
For more information, write to us: namaste@Z47.com.
Stay connected with Z47.

Watch more such podcasts

Consumer
November 10, 2025

The Chinese Internet Empire

Consumer
May 9, 2025

Where to play: Strategic Revenue Choices for Consumer Brands

Consumer
August 13, 2021

Why we invested in Myra - a potent synthesis of technology and operations

Consumer
February 25, 2025

Deconstructing P&L: What Most Founders Misunderstand

Article
Listen to article

How It All Started

Somewhere during 2024, I was at yet another event, watching panelists swap anecdotes and generic advice, when it hit me "Can events truly deliver value to founders beyond networking opportunities?”

So come November, we created something different - The Consumer Unicorn Blueprint. The intention was to merge wisdom (and warmth) from successful founders with the cold reality of data and benchmarks. We chose the (obvious, but criminally under-used) P&L statement to structure the discussion.

Kickoff: The Event

We were fortunate to have exceptional panellists who were willing to participate in this experiment:
> Varun Alagh (Honasa/Mamaearth)  
> Abhiraj Bhal (Urban Company)  
> Revant Bhate (Mosaic Wellness)  
> Avnish Bajaj (Z47)

The event received rave reviews (in our biased view, at least). In any case, energized by the format we decided to launch this series. If the event was the first step, step two begins with what was learnt and build on it.  

Reimagining the P&L: More Strategy, Less Accounting Trauma

When most founders hear ‘P&L’ they’ll instinctively fire up a spreadsheet, thinking unit economics, cost levers, runway and burn rates. Here, we implore you to look at the P&L in more imaginative ways.

Take Gross Margin – the mind races to COGS, pricing, discounting etc. But reframe it as "What to build vs. what to buy" and suddenly you're having a different conversation. It's the difference between:

Company A: "We invest in designers, who can create great prints and silhouettes.  We do this 3 quarters ahead of the season, sourcing product from vendors.

Company B: "We built a supply chain that goes from social trend to store shelves in 3 weeks flat."

Same category, wildly different businesses. Look no further than Zara (Inditex) to see the magic an innocent question (build vs buy) can unlock. Shein, Lenskart and Country Delight, I’d argue, drank the magic potion too. With this in mind – we chose to reframe the P&L into questions that can help a Founder choose/craft her business model.

Deconstructing the P&L

The Strategic Questions  

Each of these “reframes” have a ‘timing and relevance’ component to it. For the 2024 edition, we decided to pick the following sub-themes to unpack these strategic choices.

1. Revenue ( TAM -> Where to Play)

A consultant’s way of asking: "Should you create a new market or fight for scraps in an existing one?" Consider the India Opportunity (below). We're tracking similar GDP per capita numbers to China in 2007. What happened next in China? Explosive growth. The question isn't just about capturing market share - it's about riding the right wave at the right time.

The India Opportunity

2. Gross Margins (COGS -> What to Build vs. Buy)

Or: which parts of the value chain should you own, and which should you outsource? Key considerations:
• When backward integration creates competitive advantage
• Identifying and capturing value chain profit pools
• Strategic choices in servitization and private labels

3. Contribution Margin (CM 1/2/3 -> How to Build)

The blueprint for sustainable growth loops.  We examined:
• Optimizing channel and category mix
• Forward integration strategies
• Building sustainable performance, brand, and user growth loops

4. Bottomline ( EBITDA, Cashflows, RoCE -> How to Sustain)

Because, eventually, everyone runs out of other people's money.

Centered on:
• Prioritizing cash flow over EBITDA when appropriate
• Deconstructing ROCE to improve returns
• Working capital optimization techniques

Coming up
This is just the appetizer. Over the next few weeks, we'll dive deeper into each section of our framework, starting with "Where to Play" - categories, TG, premiumization, monetization and how our Panelists reframe the “Market creation” conundrum.  
We are excited about the innovation and growth opportunities in this sector.

If you are considering building in the footwear space, we’d love to chat.
Drop us a line at consumer@matrixpartners.in

Learnt something new? Follow us!

Vs NIFTY 500
+9.1%
Since Jan 2024
USD/INR
₹95.19
▲ +0.6%
Daily change • 1 Ju1 2025
128.1
▲ +28.1%
Since Jan 2024
NIFTY 500
129.1
▲ +19.0%
Since Jan 2024

Index Performance

+28.1%
Since Jan 2024
NIFTY 500
+19.0%
Since Jan 2024

Z47^fortyseven is up +23.9% since its January 2024 base date, versus Nifty 500's +18.4%, ahead by 550 bps.

The cohort moved +4.7% over the month versus Nifty 500's +2.5%, leading by 220 bps.

Anchored in domestic demand and rising digital adoption, the cohort remained resilient amid global headwinds.

Consumer Tech was the best-performing sector at +9.2% last month, driven by sustained growth in consumer demand and strength in consumer-internet platforms.

Largest Constituents  ·  The Names That Anchor The Index

1.
Eternal
Quick-commerce leadership and continued investment
▲ +12.8%
2.
Groww
Broking market-share gains and margin-funding growth.
▲ +10.4%
3.
Lenskart
Store densification and margin expansion.
▲ +2.4%

Top Gainers  ·  Key Drivers

1 MONTH RETURN
1.
CarTrade
Auto-marketplace dominance and a cash-rich balance sheet.
▲ +59.4%
2.
 Amagi Media Labs
Profitability turnaround and AI-led cloud media adoption.
▲ +31.4%

Top Laggards  ·  Key Drivers

1 MONTH RETURN
1.
Fractal Analytics
Enterprise AI spending trends and post-listing share supply.
▼ -10.8%
2.
MedPlus Health
Pharmacy-margin pressure and competitive intensity.
▼ -6.6%

Key Themes  ·  Latest Results

In Q4FY26, Z47^fortyseven's cohort grew top line ~39% YoY, more than 3x the broad market's ~12% growth.

Operating leverage lifted net margins around 500 bps into positive territory, even as broad-market net margins remained roughly flat.

With 40 of 47 companies now profitable, the cohort reflects a broader shift toward profitable growth over growth at any cost.

AI adoption runs deeper across this cohort than in the broader market, with companies using it to drive growth and reshape demand, not just improve efficiency.

Cash generation is increasingly defining the winners, enabling market leaders like Eternal, CarTrade, and PB Fintech to fund acquisitions and expansion from their own balance sheets.

Market & Macro Context

The cohort saw several block deals this month, including sizeable stake sales in Lenskart, Delhivery, Honasa, and Shadowfax.

Ownership continues to shift from foreign investors to domestic institutions, creating a more durable shareholder base.

AI remained the defining technology investment theme, driving capital deployment across both private and public markets.

IPO Takeaway · Kissht

Listed May 2026

A modest listing pop followed by strong post-listing gains reinforced the market's preference for asset quality and disciplined underwriting over pure loan-book growth.

The listing helped reset perceptions around unsecured lending, creating a constructive valuation anchor for the issuers that follow.

The buyer mix was a notable positive — strong participation from long-only domestic institutions supporting a durable post-listing ownership base.

Net Read

Fundamentals continued to strengthen across the cohort, with growth, margins, and cash generation improving in tandem.

Performance dispersion widened, with profitability and earnings quality increasingly distinguishing the strongest performers from the rest.

Disclaimer

Z47^fortyseven is published for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, or any offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy or sell securities. Index performance is historical and should not be construed as indicative of future results.

Explore the live index
Read Previous Article On Land & Expand
Read Next Article On Land & Expand